Whether it's legitimate or not is irrelevant, because it now exists, and that cannot be undone. In a similar way, it's arguable that Pakistan shouldn't exist, but that cannot be undone without the exile or genocide of an entire country.

Re: Israel's creation involved the forced displacement of Palestinians from their land, making its claim to the land rooted in dispossession and injustice, which undermines its legitimacy.

Argument: Whether it's legitimate or not is irrelevant, because it now exists, and that cannot be undone. In a similar way, it's arguable that Pakistan shouldn't exist, but that cannot be undone without the exile or genocide of an entire country.

Oppose an existing rebuttal to this argument or make your own.

Add Rebuttal

Current rebuttals (click to oppose):

Back to Home